« Esref Armagan | Main | iPhoto 5 »

January 30, 2005

Comments

Darren

Thanks for that. McQueen's moving image is more problematic than, say, Simone's song for a few reasons:

* A moving image interacting with the world of the commercial is simply far more tangible and noteworthy than a background song. I mute commercials when watching TV, but I'd still see Mr. McQueen.

* McQueen is active in the commercial. Someone hands him the keys, he climbs in and drives off. He (or rather, his image) is unquestionably endorsing the product. A background song, I think, in our world of soundtracks, doesn't carry the same implication.

* Huh, just two reasons, really.

Mark

Those are reasonable points.

While I think I agree with you at a "gut feel" level that this is somehow qualitatively worse than my Nina Simone example (Nina Simone fans may disagree,) I also feel that we may have to just grin and bear it. Especially if we are also people who think that mash-ups are cool and that creative commons licenses will enable all sorts of funky creative repurposing of existing material if only more people would use them.

If we say that what Ford is doing - with the permission of all of the owners of rights to the images used - is wrong, while remixing news footage of Dick Cheney to have him say "fuck" a lot is a blow for freedom, then we are guilty of creating a double standard.

BTW, I don't think Hitler has an estate that might block reuse of his image, so I suspect there is some other reason why it hasn't been used in a commercial yet.

Lou Holland

Speaking of the new Ford Mustang commercial with Steve McQueen...It's been airing in the US since Oct. 2004 and is coming to Canada soon. I think it's the best commercial of all time. Steve McQueen, the image of the Mustang combined with the 'Field of Dreams' concept...awesome! I found the website for the Canadian actor, David Stuart, who is the living actor in the spot. He has a 1 minute copy of the commercial as well as spots for Kyocera, MSN, Greyhound, Excite.com and others. Again, it's www.david-stuart.net

The comments to this entry are closed.

My latest @flickr


Recently Read

Recent Listening

Not so locals